Augmenting Glutathione in Chronic Fatigue Syndrome (ME/CFS) by Rich Van Konynenburg
There are several ways to augment one's glutathione. It is a good idea to proceed slowly at first if glutathione has been depleted for an extended period of time (months to years), because toxins and infections may have been allowed to build up in the absence of sufficient glutathione to keep them under control. If glutathione is then brought up rapidly, the mobilization of toxins can produce a Jarisch Herxheimer reaction, which is an exacerbation of symptoms that can make a person feel very unpleasant. Also, see the particular comments about mercury below.
Here are some approaches for building glutathione (Note that names of products, laboratories and suppliers are given for information only, not as recommendations. There may be others not mentioned that are satisfactory):
1. ORAL SUPPLEMENTS such as the "nondenatured" or "native" whey protein products (ImmunoPro Rx or RenewPro), the "undenatured" whey protein products (e.g. Immunocal, ImuPlus, etc.), such as from Prohealth or Needs or IHerb the fermented goat-milk-based version of whey protein, Goatein, available from www.gardenoflifeusa.com, amino acid precursors including N-acetylcysteine, glycine and glutamic acid (such as from Jeff Clark at http://www.cfsn.com), N-acetylcysteine together with dietary protein, or reduced glutathione supplements per se, both available from health food stores. One supplier of oral reduced glutathione is TheranaturalsA relatively new oral supplement is Lipoceutical Glutathione, which is reduced glutathione encapsulated in tiny liposomes made from soy-based phosphatidylcholine, available from http://www.wellnesshealth.com. This latter form is relatively expensive, but more of the glutathione is absorbed intact and appears to be carried to various cells of the body encapsulated in the liposomes.
Another liposomal form of glutathione called LipoFlow is available at http://www.arrowheadhealthworks.com. (See update at bottom of page for more information on these products.)
No prescription is required for the above oral supplements.
Whey Products.
ImmunoPro Rx and RenewPro are actually "native" or "nondenatured" being made
from whey that has not been heated to high temperatures or treated with acid as
in cheese making, which the "undenatured" products' starting material have
undergone, so that they have more cysteine present as actual cysteine per se
rather than the oxidized form cystine, and cysteine is more useable by the liver
for making glutathione, particularly in a person who is depleted in glutathione.
The "undenatured" and "nondenatured" whey protein products can be problematical
for those with allergies to whey proteins, and the goat-milk based version
Goatein may be helpful in such cases, even though the fermentation process
likely converts much of the cysteine to cystine. Many people with dairy
allergies are actually sensitivities to pasteurized milk proteins or allergies
to casein, which is the part of milk protein that goes into the curd fraction,
rather than into whey, so a dairy food allergy or sensitivity may not be an
allergy to nondenatured whey protein.
The amino acid precursors should not present problems of allergic reactions, but
should be taken with high quality dietary protein to ensure that they are used
effectively and that if mercury is present, its transport into the brain is not
encouraged. Some PWCs do not tolerate glutamic acid well. In such cases,
glutamine (or better yet, a product called Glutimmune, available from
http://www.wellwisdom.com) can be
substituted for the glutamic acid, and taken together with N-acetylcysteine and
glycine.
The reduced glutathione supplements are a more expensive approach than the whey
or NAC-based approaches. Free reduced glutathione appears to be largely broken
down in the gut into amino acids, so there is probably not an advantage to
taking regular capsules of reduced glutathione per se except for the cells of
the intestines themselves, but Lipoceutical Glutathione is not significantly
broken down in the gut and is able to enter cells in its intact form more
easily, and LipoFlow likely behaves similarly. These latter two products may
actually be absorbed through the wall of the stomach.
Mercury Issues. If there is a high level of mercury in the body, such as can occur if glutathione has been low for an extended period of time (months to years) and the person either has silver amalgam fillings in their teeth or they have consumed a significant amount of large, predatory fish, including tuna, then caution should be exercised by limiting the dosages of oral supplements that supply amino acids to the liver for making glutathione. There are two reasons for this:
The first is that mercury can be moved into the brain from other parts of the body by cysteine or N-acetylcysteine if the dosages are too high. Dr. David Quig of Doctors Data Laboratories recommends limiting the dosage of NAC to 300 mg per day and taking it with a high protein diet if heavy metals are elevated.
The second reason is that mercury can block the utilization of cysteine, and if cysteine rises too high, it can act as a neurotoxin. (This last is also the reason L-cysteine is not recommended as a supplement for building glutathione.) It's a good idea to measure the blood plasma level of cysteine periodically when building glutathione, to make sure it is not rising too high.
If elevated mercury is suspected, it is a good idea to test for mercury and detox it carefully if it is present, with the help of a doctor experienced in doing this. The best test is a collection of urine for 6 hours, preceded by a challenge with the chelator DMSA (succimer). A very small dosage of DMSA should be tried first, to make sure there is not an allergic reaction to it. A test of this type is offered as a Toxic Metals Panel by http://www.doctorsdata.com.
If there is elevated mercury, it may also be wise to begin building glutathione using one of the approaches below, which put glutathione per se into the blood, rather than one of the oral approaches that help the liver to make glutathione. This may help to remove the mercury more "gently," starting with the kidneys, which absorb most of the glutathione put directly into the blood.
Oral supplements are probably the best way to raise the glutathione level in the liver, since the liver gets first access to oral supplements via the portal vein, and it is normally the main producer of glutathione in the body and an exporter of glutathione to the systemic blood and the bile. The liver is probably not able to take glutathione from the blood for its own use, so approaches that put glutathione per se into the blood probably are not very helpful in directly building glutathione in the liver.
2. Intramuscular injections, as pioneered by Dr. Patricia Salvato in Houston. She injects 100 mg of glutathione with 1 mg of ATP, intramuscularly, 2 times per week. One source of IM glutathione is McGuff Compounding Pharmacy in Santa Ana, CA (phone: (877) 444-1133, fax: (877)444-1155). This probably benefits most the muscle into which it is injected, but it is also reported to have systemic effects.
3. Intravenous injections, and particularly fast I.V. pushes, as advocated and used by Dr. Patricia Kane and her co-authors of The Detoxx Book as part of their overall detox protocol. The book says they do an I.V. push over 3 to 5 minutes starting with 1,500 mg of glutathione in 12 cc of sterile water for adults, and going as high as 2,500 mg in 15 cc of sterile water, one to two time per week for 3 to 6 months or more. They suggest Wellness Health and Pharmaceuticals in Birmingham, AL as the source for injectable reduced glutathione (phone: (800)227-2627, fax: (205)879-6551).
Intravenous glutathione injections seem to be becoming more prevalent. I think they were pioneered in the U.S. by Dr. David Perlmutter (after initial work in Italy by Dr. Secchi) for the treatment of Parkinson's disease, but they are being used in other disorders as well. Several cell types are able to extract glutathione from the blood, break it down, import the pieces, and resynthesize it inside the cell, via the gamma glutamyl cycle. Other types of cells can import glutathione intact from the blood. This approach requires a visit to a doctor's office, and it is relatively expensive to get these injections repeatedly.
(*From Sue Bailey: I've just learned of another source for IV glutathione fast pushes:www.Infuserveamerica.com/index.htm I think there are several good things about Infuserve America; They are cheaper. A pre-loaded syringe containing 2000 mg of glutathione is $12.50. (This is the wholesale price, and they explain on the website how they can sell it so cheap. ( 2.) A pre-loaded syringe is easier to use. With Wellness, I had to pay for and use four separate items--a 30 ml syringe, a disposable needle, a vial of glutathione and a vial of normal saline. Then I had to draw the two liquids into the syringe. Infuserve makes up a new batch of GSH every week).
4. Glutathione suppositories from a compounding pharmacy. One source is Hopewell Pharmacy in New Jersey (phone: (800)792-6670). One person told me they use suppositories containing 250 mg of glutathione. Another told me that they are also available in 500 mg doses from http://www.wellnesshealth.com. I don't know how much gets into the blood with this method, but I suspect that it is substantial. This is a relatively inexpensive way to put glutathione into the blood. I think a prescription is required for this form. 5. Glutathione nasal spray. I've heard of people formulating their own by mixing glutathione solution from compounding pharmacies with saline solution. I don't know how much glutathione is absorbed into the blood this way, but I suspect it is less than with the suppositories. It's important to keep the solution refrigerated and to use it soon after it is mixed, because the reduced glutathione undergoes chemical changes over time in solution. 6. Glutathione transdermal skin creams (available from http://www.kirkmanlabs.com) (no prescription required). Lotions are also sold. These may have a strong smell. A stabilized reduced glutathione transdermal gel is available from http://www.leesilsby.com. I don't know how much of the glutathione gets into the blood with these products. 7. Glutathione sublingual troches from a compounding pharmacy. One source is Lionville Natural Pharmacy in Lionville, PA (phone: (877) 363-7474, fax: (610)363-5707) These are made in orange and blueberry flavors, and are composed of a very firm gel. There are also hard troches in orange flavor. I don't know how much gets into the blood. 8. Nebulizer application to the lungs, as pioneered by Dr. Buhl et al. at the NIH and as described by Dr. Julian Whitaker in his newsletter Health and Healing. Dr. Buhl used 600 mg in a few milliliters of water per application. Dr. Whitaker uses 300 mg, two times per day, applied over 5 to 10 minutes with a nebulizer, available from a medical supply company. He recommends Wellness Health and Pharmaceuticals (numbers given above) and California Pharmacy and Compounding Center as sources for the glutathione. Nebulized glutathione is being used for a variety of lung diseases now, including chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), cystic fibrosis, interstitial pulmonary fibrosis and multiple chemical sensitivity. There are reports that quite a bit gets into the blood using this approach. Valerie Hudson, who has helped to pioneer use of aerosol glutathione in cystic fibrosis, suggests L-Glutathione Plus capsules from Theranaturals mixed with boiled water, applied with a nebulizer. No prescription is required for the capsules, and it may also be possible to get a nebulizer without a prescription. Valerie suggests one capsule containing 200 mg of reduced glutathione mixed into 3 or 4 ml of boiled water. An important feature of this source of glutathione (available without a prescription) is that it is buffered with sodium bicarbonate. Clark Bishop, M.D., wrote me that this buffering is important, because if the pH is too acid, it can lead to bronchospasm when nebulizing. People who are subject to asthmatic attacks should not use nebulized glutathione, as it can result in bronchospasm, thought to be caused by the sulfites that form when glutathione is mixed with water.It's also very important in nebulizing to
use pure, boiled or sterile water, and a clean nebulizer in order to prevent
introducing infections or respirable particulates into the lungs. Because of
these issues, nebulizing is best done under the supervision of a doctor or a
respiratory therapist.
9.
Take turmeric
(the yellow
spice in mustard and in food eaten in India). The curcumin in this spice has
been shown to stimulate glutathione production.
Some people are using more than one of these modes simultaneously. My current
opinion is that it is a good idea to start at low dosages to see how well it is
tolerated, and then work up as it is tolerated. I think that a combination of an
oral approach to build the liver's ability to make glutathione combined with one
or more of the approaches that puts intact glutathione into the blood is
probably the optimum way to build glutathione.
TESTING GLUTATHIONE
It is a good idea to measure the glutathione level before starting to try to build glutathione to see if it is low, and then, if it is low, to measure again after trying to build it for a few months, to see how your approach is working. There are several ways to do this. Probably the cheapest is to measure the red blood cell glutathione. Two labs that offer this test are Immunosciences Lab (www.immuno-sci-lab.com) and Amscot Medical Labs. Great Smokies Diagnostic Lab offers an assessment of the glutathione detoxification pathway in its Comprehensive Detox panel.
An analysis of urinary organic acids by either
Great Plans Laboratory or
Metamatrix will
give an indirect assessment of glutathione status, particularly in the skeletal
muscles (via citric acid and alpha ketoglutaric acid measurements) and the
kidneys (via pyroglutamic acid aka 5-oxo-proline measurement). A measurement of
glutathione function in the lymphocytes is offered by www.spectracell.com. I
favor the Spectracell test if a person can afford it. Otherwise, the red blood
cell test is still useful.
It's also a good idea to measure the blood plasma level of cysteine periodically
when building glutathione, to make sure it is not rising too high. If a person
is high in mercury, this can block the pathways that use cysteine, and it can
build up.
In the future, I hope that studies will be done of genetic variations in CFS
that may be behind the tendency toward glutathione depletion. Such genetic
variations have been found in autism If anyone reading this finds errors or
knows of things that have been left out, please let me know at
richvank@.... Thank you.
Rich Van Konynenburg (6/19/05)
UPDATE:
Rich recently posted some more thoughts on CFSFMExperimental@yahoo.com on Liposomal Glutathione products (12/12/05)Liposomal Glutathione - It now looks as though
there are three liposomal glutathione products on the market, namely Essential
GSH, Lipoceutical Glutathione, and LipoFlow Glutathione. The prices have also
come down some. Looks as though there is some market-driven competition
going on. Wellness Health has developed their own liposomal glutathione product
(Essential GSH) independently of Dr. Tim Guilford, the person behind the
development of Lipoceutical Glutathione.
Two sizes of bottles (2 oz. and 4 oz.) are being offered for both Essential GSH
and Lipoceutical Glutathione, and for each size, the prices are the same for the
two products ($35 and $65). That is, they are the same if you buy Essential GSH
from www.essentialgsh.com and Lipoceutical Glutathione from www.GSHNow.com.
Wellness Health still has some Lipoceutical Glutathione on hand, and they are
offering it at $50 for a 2 oz. bottle. The websites for these two products
don't specify how much actual glutathione is in each sized bottle.
LipoFlow Glutathione is being offered in 2 oz. bottles, with two different
amounts of actual glutathione, by www.lipflow.com. The one containing 1000 mg of
glutathione is offered for $29, and the one with 2267 mg of glutathione is only
one dollar more, at $30, which is very interesting! With this kind of pricing,
I gather that the major cost of production must not be in the glutathione
itself, but rather in the liposomal encapsulation process. The maker of
LipoFlow Glutathione told me at the DAN! meeting that he gets his glutathione
from Japan. They meet his specification, but he didn't seem to know how they
actually produce it. I think it is made by yeasts.
The producers of both Essential GSH and LipoFlow Glutathione emphasize that they
use "essential phospholipids" in their liposomal process. The implication is
that the body can use these phospholipids as well as using the glutathione. I
understand that Lipoceutical Glutathione uses "hydroxylated phospholipids." I
really don't know how important this difference is.
I also really don't know at this point which of these products will work best
for PWCs, or whether they will all work about the same, for the same total
amount of glutathione. In the absence of clinical trials, I don't think anyone
can really say. I think it would be worthwhile to know how much actual
glutathione is in 2 oz. of Lipoceutical Glutathione and in 2 oz. of Essential
Glutathione. This is probably specified on the bottles. If anyone has these
bottles, I would be interested to know what they say.
Readisorb. I mentioned a new liposomal glutathione product called "Readisorb." I checked it
out on the web, and it is none other than Lipoceutical Glutathione with a
different label! It appears that Dr. Tim Guilford has renamed his company "Your
Energy Systems, LLC," from its old name "Wellness Products," now that Wellness
Health Pharmacy has introduced its own liposomal glutathione product, called
Essential GSH.
Dr. Guilford is still selling his liposomal glutathione product at
www.gshnow.com on a retail basis as
Lipoceutical Glutathione, with the price competitive with the price of Essential
GSH, but he has also relabled it as Readisorb Liposomal Glutathione, which he is
selling to licensed healthcare practitioners and selected distributors. In
addition, he has introduced a liposomal methyl B12 sublingual spray, and a
liposomal melatonin sublingual spray. He is advertising the methyl B12 spray as
a means to support the methylation cycle, and he is advertising the melatonin
spray for its antioxidant properties.
From the labels of these two new products, it appears that he is using the same
process to form the liposomes for them as for Lipoceutical Glutathione, since
they all contain purified water, glycerin, hydroxylated soy lecithin, citric
acid and potassium sorbate.
I think this is an interesting development. Dr. Guilford has clearly taken on
board the significance of the paper by Jill James et al., which he cites twice
on his webpage, and he is carefully implying that sublingual liposomal methyl
B12 might be useful for the treatment of autism. (Note that makers of
supplements can't come right out and say that their products can be used to
treat diseases, or they will get in trouble with the FDA, which holds that that
makes them drugs, and without FDA approval, drugs cannot be sold.)
As far as I
know, this is the first liposomal methyl B12 on the market. He doesn't mention
using it for CFS on his webpage, but I communicated with him some time back
about that, so he is aware of my thinking. This product might be an good way for
PWCs to take methyl B12. I don't know what the cost will be. It probably
depends on how much markup individual healthcare practitioners will give it.
I have no financial interest in these products -
Rich
(A Yahoo discussion group devoted to Rich's ideas has been formed. You can find it at http://health.groups.yahoo.com/group/CFS_Yasko/)
Energy Treatments / Treating Glutathione Depletion-Methylation Blockades / Glutathione Depletion